How we score
Every product gets five sub-scores from 1 to 5, weighted into a score out of 100. We don’t accept reader reviews, votes or submissions; every score is ours.
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Evidence & honest claims | 25% |
| Value (3-year cost) | 25% |
| Ease of use & upkeep | 20% |
| Trial, returns & warranty | 15% |
| No lock-in | 15% |
- Evidence & honest claims: does independent research support the main benefit, and does the brand avoid overclaiming?
- Value: price, or true 3-year cost including required or typical subscriptions, against the category.
- Ease of use & upkeep: setup, maintenance, washing, comfort.
- Trial, returns & warranty: how safe it is to try.
- No lock-in: do you need a subscription to get what you paid for?
True 3-year cost = upfront price + 3 years of subscription (2 if year one is included). Optional subscriptions are included when most features depend on them; we say so on each page.
Unknowns: if a policy isn’t verified we give a neutral 3. If the price isn’t verified, value is 0 and we show “unknown.” We never estimate prices or specs.
Scores are editorial and based on published specs, pricing, policies and research. Unless a page says otherwise, we haven’t lab-tested the product. Affiliate relationships never change a score.
Get Sleep Wins Weekly
One email a week: price drops on gear we've scored, new launches, one head-to-head, and a short sleep coaching tip.
Signup opens soon. We're setting up the list now.